How do I remove a new tub/shower installation that was messed up by the previous installer?
Asked by Emma Jones 
6 months ago
Last Updated: June 9, 2024
I just set up a new tub/shower, but now I have no idea how to remove it. It seems like the previous installer did a terrible job.
Cut the item using a flathead screwdriver
I agree with the previous answer, it’s pretty straightforward.
Nipple extractor…
THIS is the important part right here!
Sometimes it can be a bit tricky, so be careful when cutting around the tub’s drain opening to avoid hitting the cast iron or porcelain. Take your time and consider asking for help from someone experienced. If I were in your shoes, I might try heating the shoe slightly to expand the threads, but only if you’re confident in your skills as too much heat could damage the porcelain. If you’re uncertain, it’s best to hire a professional plumber to avoid having to replace the tub.
Hey , have you realized that it’s actually made of fiberglass?
Doesn’t work on Fiberglass…and that tub is actually made of Fiberglass.
Try cutting it off from the bottom. Fiberglass can break easily. You’ll have the rubber washer below to prevent cutting too far. A multi tool with a carbide blade is essential.
I usually use a dremel with a small cutting wheel to make 2 cuts, and then I use a heavy flat tip screwdriver to pop it out. Just be cautious with that Fiberglass. I’ve actually been doing this for 42 years.
I checked it out and you’re spot on, I must be losing my eyesight. I could’ve sworn I saw a cast tub. If it were up to me, I’d give it a go, but if they struggle to move the fitting, I’d suggest they seek assistance.
I took a look and you’re absolutely right, I must be going blind. I thought I spotted a cast tub. If it were me, I’d give it a shot, but if they can’t move the fitting, I’d recommend they call for help.
Lol. Cast tubs are much more forgiving. Damaging the fiberglass one is pretty easy. But yeah, that’s good advice. Just wanted to give you a little tease. 😆
That’s why sometimes it’s best to reach out for help. It took years to master the skills you have. I agree with your solution – it’s what I would have done. I spent over 40 years in the trade, but I still remember how important it was to be careful not to damage the tub. They don’t have much experience with this.
Yeah, I’m not going to bother calling someone for this. If I called someone for every little thing like this, nothing would ever get done. I’m not shy about putting in the effort 😂😂
I really enjoy visiting his website because I can chat back and forth with the guys I used to work with. We used to tease each other all the time to make the day go by faster.
Right. Yeah. It was just a small jab. Put on your glasses, grandpa. Lol. Haha. Have a great day 😊
I wasn’t referring to the job itself, but if you were to buy a new tub, the cost would be substantial. I believe you are capable of doing your own work, but I’ve seen experienced professionals make mistakes with things like these.
I wouldn’t bother, it’s all junk, including the fiberglass tub. If you really want to salvage either piece for some reason, you can try using an extractor or carefully cutting it.
It may seem like a real nightmare. The tub extractors might work if the threads aren’t completely rusted, but that’s usually the case. You could try holding the tub side of the drain in place with the extractor suggested above while turning the bottom tail piece to get better leverage. I wouldn’t recommend attempting to cut and pry out the drain unless you’re extremely cautious; I’ve damaged tubs trying this before, and if you’re not experienced, you could easily damage the fiberglass tub as well. Another suggestion is to cut from the bottom. This option appears to be the most suitable for you, cutting flush with the fiberglass without causing any damage. This will separate the male threads from the female ones, and both sides will become loose. It seems like you could use a hacksaw in there instead of a reciprocating saw for a neater cut.
Hey , I think if he holds the top flange in place, he could gently tap the drain underneath to loosen it.
Try using a metal blade on a Sawzall or multitool to remove the collar
A couple of good channel locks will work perfectly
Hennerberg did you try using channel locks? The inside was all torn up because it wouldn’t move, do you really think channel locks will help?
Hennerberg why would you clamp onto the tub side?
Hennerberg asking for help because he doesn’t know the way… you show him how to do it, then he mocks you for not knowing the way… 🤔
Seemed like he genuinely asked a question…
Check out this link: https://youtu.be/0poO0fky7Mw?si=XHPB3gBvK8WAxgvu
There’s this woman giving it a shot…
Hey, I could use something a bit stronger. There must be a reason why it broke initially.
It’s actually called ‘wedging’… I prefer using channel locks… I intentionally break the middle part, it’s quicker and usually they don’t come out in one piece after being installed for a while
Oh really? You have no idea what you’re talking about…. I’ve been a master for 25 years… that’s the most aggressive way possible… You should heat the 90 underneath, it will spin out quickly
Hey, she’s not turning, bub
Hennerberg was simply offering a suggestion on how to remove the drain, there was no need to respond rudely. Some people view photos on small phones or have difficulty with vision. We are all here to assist each other. If you don’t like the response, just move on.
Yes I have tried that method. You insert one end into the hole and use the other to twist it. Just place the top of the channel lock in the hole and push sideways. By the way, why the rude comment?
Apparently not the best at doing this lol, I’ve removed a lot of them while renovating apartments and houses.
I know, right? –
Hey , try using channel locks as a first option. If that doesn’t work, apply some heat. If all else fails, it might be time to call a plumber.
Hey , if using heat and channel locks doesn’t work, you might want to consider getting the grinder out.
Haha, definitely don’t miss out on that!
Those old brass tub drains tend to get heavily calcified. I recently had to replace a drain that was chrome plated and very old, which was quite stubborn. I shared my two solutions with others.
Check out a YouTube video with plenty of demonstrations on the proper way to cut that out.
The multi-tool was used to cut through the metal blade flush with the bottom of the tub.
Instead of using plan B, I found that using a multi-tool to cut the lip that holds the drain in place works wonders. Start by prying with a flat head screwdriver, then bend with channel locks. Be cautious as ceramic glaze can chip easily.
You could try getting a drain wrench that might be effective, or use the handles of a channel lock with another pair beneath and turn them in opposite directions.
It seems like noticed that the cross in the drain is broken. You could cut a section to use a chisel and hammer it in a leftward direction to loosen the threads. Is the escutcheon ring male threaded to the female threaded drain?
Is saying that the tub is not connected to the plumbing. He needs to remove the old one before installing this pre-owned tub.
The best method is to cut from underneath using a Sawzall or oscillating tool
Seriously! I’m explaining to him how to remove it with the broken cross-section. Try using a channel lock – it’s been working great for me every day
You should consider calling a plumber.